Cumberbatch As The Doctor?
Posted in Interviews, Other Projects on July 22nd, 2010 by Sean – 12 CommentsThere’s been a fair amount of hullaballoo today about Benedict Cumberbatch’s oblique comments to DigitalSpy about his potential future involvement in Doctor Who. You can see the clip here:
Personally, I’m rather unhappy about this for several reasons — first, this was press for Sherlock, and Cumberbatch’s response to the question undercuts the very reason he was being interviewed to begin with. Cumberbatch may be excited about the prospects of taking on a new, bigger role, but why admit that before Sherlock has even aired? Additionally, count me among those who find the specific tenor of his statements to be more than a little arrogant; sure, after playing Sherlock Holmes, it might be hard to be a guest star on Doctor Who, but excellent, more established actors (Derek Jacobi, Bill Nighy, Timothy Dalton, Toby Jones, David Morrissey, and now Michael Gambon, to name but a few) have all stepped into the guest-starring role.
Finally, I’m a huge, huge fan of Matt Smith’s performance as the Doctor — in one series, he’s proven himself to be the equal of any of his predecessors. Perhaps this is confirmation that Smith truly is on the way out, as has been rumored (I certainly hope not); if so, this isn’t the way for this news to be revealed. If Smith’s days in the TARDIS are not numbered, then Cumberbatch’s excited, anticipatory smirk at the end of the interview seems astoundingly presumptuous. Regardless, I ain’t happy about this either way you cut it.
Update: And, just to be clear, there’s no evidence yet that Cumberbatch is actually being pursued for the role. From more recent press today by BBC News:
Wouldn’t Benedict Cumberbatch make an ideal Doctor Who?
“There is no vacancy,” said Moffat. “Matt Smith is the Doctor and he’s been an astonishing success and – who knows – maybe he’ll never regenerate again.”
Hopefully, that’s that.












